Attending to History' in Major System Change in Healthcare in England: Specialist Cancer Surgery Service Reconfiguration
Boaden, R. J.
Black, G. B.
Clarke, C. S.
Ramsay, A. I. G.
Shackley, David C
Fulop, N. J.
MetadataShow full item record
AbstractBackground The reconfiguration of specialist hospital services, with service provision concentrated in a reduced number of sites, is one example of major system change (MSC) for which there is evidence of improved patient outcomes. This paper explores the reconfiguration of specialist oesophago-gastric (OG) cancer surgery services in a large urban area of England (Greater Manchester, GM), with a focus on the role of history in this change process and how reconfiguration was achieved after previous failed attempts. Methods This study draws on qualitative research from a mixed-methods evaluation of the reconfiguration of specialist cancer surgery services in GM. Forty-six interviews with relevant stakeholders were carried out, along with ~160 hours of observations at meetings and the acquisition of ~300 pertinent documents. Thematic analysis using deductive and inductive approaches was undertaken, guided by a framework of ‘simple rules’ for MSC. Results Through an awareness of, and attention to, history, leaders developed a change process which took into account previous unsuccessful reconfiguration attempts, enabling them to reduce the impact of potentially challenging issues. Interviewees described attending to issues involving competition between provider sites, change leadership, engagement with stakeholders, and the need for a process of change resilient to challenge. Conclusion Recognition of, and response to, history, using a range of perspectives, enabled this reconfiguration. Particularly important was the way in which history influenced and informed other aspects of the change process and the influence of stakeholder power. This study provides further learning about MSC and the need for a range of perspectives to enable understanding. It shows how learning from history can be used to enable successful change.
CitationPerry C, Boaden RJ, Black GB, Clarke CS, Darley S, Ramsay AIG, et al. "Attending to History" in Major System Change in Healthcare in England: Specialist Cancer Surgery Service Reconfiguration. Int J Health Policy Manag. 2022.
JournalInt J Health Policy Manag
- Reorganising specialist cancer surgery for the twenty-first century: a mixed methods evaluation (RESPECT-21).
- Authors: Fulop NJ, Ramsay AI, Vindrola-Padros C, Aitchison M, Boaden RJ, Brinton V, Clarke CS, Hines J, Hunter RM, Levermore C, Maddineni SB, Melnychuk M, Moore CM, Mughal MM, Perry C, Pritchard-Jones K, Shackley DC, Vickers J, Morris S
- Issue date: 2016 Nov 25
- Understanding perspectives on major system change: A comparative case study of public engagement and the implementation of urgent and emergency care system reconfiguration.
- Authors: Foley C, Droog E, Healy O, McHugh S, Buckley C, Browne JP
- Issue date: 2017 Jul
- Authors: Michaels J, Wilson E, Maheswaran R, Radley S, Jones G, Tong TS, Kaltenthaler E, Aber A, Booth A, Buckley Woods H, Chilcott J, Duncan R, Essat M, Goka E, Howard A, Keetharuth A, Lumley E, Nawaz S, Paisley S, Palfreyman S, Poku E, Phillips P, Rooney G, Thokala P, Thomas S, Tod A, Wickramasekera N, Shackley P
- Issue date: 2021 Apr
- How to Cost the Implementation of Major System Change for Economic Evaluations: Case Study Using Reconfigurations of Specialist Cancer Surgery in Part of London, England.
- Authors: Clarke CS, Vindrola-Padros C, Levermore C, Ramsay AIG, Black GB, Pritchard-Jones K, Hines J, Smith G, Bex A, Mughal M, Shackley D, Melnychuk M, Morris S, Fulop NJ, Hunter RM
- Issue date: 2021 Nov