Can patient decision aids reduce decisional conflict in a de-escalation of breast radiotherapy clinical trial? The PRIMETIME Study Within a Trial implemented using a cluster stepped-wedge trial design
AuthorsBhattacharya, I. S.
Haviland, J. S.
Kirby, A. M.
Kirwan, Cliona C
Coles, C. E
Bliss, J. M.
AffiliationThe Institute of Cancer Research Clinical Trials and Statistics Unit (ICR-CTSU), London, UK.
MetadataShow full item record
AbstractBackground: For patients with early breast cancer considered at very-low risk of local relapse, risks of radiotherapy may outweigh the benefits. Decisions regarding treatment omission can lead to patient uncertainty (decisional conflict), which may be lessened with patient decision aids (PDA). PRIMETIME (ISRCTN 41579286) is a UK-led biomarker-directed study evaluating omission of adjuvant radiotherapy in breast cancer; an embedded Study Within A Trial (SWAT) investigated whether PDA reduces decisional conflict using a cluster stepped-wedge trial design. Methods: PDA diagrams and a video explaining risks and benefits of radiotherapy were developed in close collaboration between patient advocates and PRIMETIME trialists. The SWAT used a cluster stepped-wedge trial design, where each cluster represented the radiotherapy centre and referring peripheral centres. All clusters began in the standard information group (patient information and diagrams) and were randomised to cross-over to the enhanced information group (standard information plus video) at 2, 4 or 6 months. Primary endpoint was the decisional conflict scale (0-100, higher scores indicating greater conflict) which was assessed on an individual participant level. Multilevel mixed effects models used a random effect for cluster and a fixed effect for each step to adjust for calendar time and clustering. Robust standard errors were also adjusted for the clustering effect. Results: Five hundred twenty-one evaluable questionnaires were returned from 809 eligible patients (64%) in 24 clusters between April 2018 and October 2019. Mean decisional conflict scores in the standard group (N = 184) were 10.88 (SD 11.82) and 8.99 (SD 11.82) in the enhanced group (N = 337), with no statistically significant difference [mean difference - 1.78, 95%CI - 3.82-0.25, p = 0.09]. Compliance with patient information and diagrams was high in both groups although in the enhanced group only 121/337 (36%) reported watching the video. Conclusion: The low levels of decisional conflict in PRIMETIME are reassuring and may reflect the high-quality information provision, such that not everyone required the video. This reinforces the importance of working with patients as partners in clinical trials especially in the development of patient-centred information and decision aids.
CitationBhattacharya IS, Haviland JS, Turner L, Stobart H, Balasopoulou A, Stones L, et al. Can patient decision aids reduce decisional conflict in a de-escalation of breast radiotherapy clinical trial? The PRIMETIME Study Within a Trial implemented using a cluster stepped-wedge trial design. Trials . 2021 Jun 14;22(1).
- Effectiveness, cost-utility and implementation of a decision aid for patients with localised prostate cancer and their partners: study protocol of a stepped-wedge cluster randomised controlled trial.
- Authors: Al-Itejawi HHM, van Uden-Kraan CF, van de Ven PM, Coupé VMH, Vis AN, Nieuwenhuijzen JA, van Moorselaar JA, Verdonck-de Leeuw IM
- Issue date: 2017 Sep 15
- Randomized controlled trial on the effect of an online decision aid for young female cancer patients regarding fertility preservation.
- Authors: Ehrbar V, Urech C, Rochlitz C, Zanetti Dällenbach R, Moffat R, Stiller R, Germeyer A, Nawroth F, Dangel A, Findeklee S, Tschudin S
- Issue date: 2019 Sep 29
- Randomized controlled trial of a patient decision-making aid for orthodontics.
- Authors: Parker K, Cunningham SJ, Petrie A, Ryan FS
- Issue date: 2017 Aug
- Impact of MyDiabetesPlan, a Web-Based Patient Decision Aid on Decisional Conflict, Diabetes Distress, Quality of Life, and Chronic Illness Care in Patients With Diabetes: Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial.
- Authors: Yu C, Choi D, Bruno BA, Thorpe KE, Straus SE, Cantarutti P, Chu K, Frydrych P, Hoang-Kim A, Ivers N, Kaplan D, Leung FH, Maxted J, Rezmovitz J, Sale J, Sodhi-Helou S, Stacey D, Telner D
- Issue date: 2020 Sep 30
- Effect of a decision aid with patient narratives in reducing decisional conflict in choice for surgery among early-stage breast cancer patients: A three-arm randomized controlled trial.
- Authors: Osaka W, Nakayama K
- Issue date: 2017 Mar