Impact of peer review in reducing uncertainty in the definition of the lung target volume among trainee oncologists
Aznar, Marianne Camille
van Herk, Marcel
AffiliationFaculty of Health Science, University of Malta, Msida, Malta
MetadataShow full item record
AbstractAIMS: To evaluate the impact of peer review and contouring workshops on reducing uncertainty in target volume delineation for lung cancer radiotherapy. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Data from two lung cancer target volume delineation courses were analysed. In total, 22 trainees in clinical oncology working across different UK centres attended these courses with priori experience in lung cancer radiotherapy. The courses were made up of short presentations and contouring practice sessions. The participants were divided into two groups and asked to first individually delineate (IND) and then individually peer review (IPR) the contours of another participant. The contours were discussed with an expert panel consisting of two consultant clinical oncologists and a consultant radiologist. Contours were analysed quantitatively by measuring the volume and local distance standard deviation (localSD) from the reference expert consensus contour and qualitatively through visual analysis. Feedback from the participants was obtained using a questionnaire. RESULTS: All participants applied minor editing to the contours during IPR, leading to a non-statistically significant reduction in the mean delineated volume (IND = 140.92 cm3, IPR = 125.26 cm3, P = 0.211). The overall interobserver variation was similar, with a localSD of 0.33 cm and 0.38 cm for the IND and IPR, respectively (P = 0.848). Six participants (29%) carried out correct major changes by either including tumour or excluding healthy tissue. One participant (5%) carried out an incorrect edit by excluding parts of the tumour, while another observer failed to identify a major contour error. The participants' level of confidence in target volume delineation increased following the course and identified the discussions with the radiologist and colleagues as the most important highlights of the course. CONCLUSION: IPR could improve target volume delineation quality among trainee oncologists by identifying most major contour errors. However, errors were also introduced after IPR, suggesting the need to further discuss major changes with a multidisciplinary team.
CitationMeijer BJ, Giugliano FP, Baan B, van der Meer JHM, Meisner S, van Roest M, et al. ATF2 and ATF7 Are Critical Mediators of Intestinal Epithelial Repair. Cell Mol Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2020;37(1):103.
- A teaching intervention in a contouring dummy run improved target volume delineation in locally advanced non-small cell lung cancer: Reducing the interobserver variability in multicentre clinical studies.
- Authors: Schimek-Jasch T, Troost EG, Rücker G, Prokic V, Avlar M, Duncker-Rohr V, Mix M, Doll C, Grosu AL, Nestle U
- Issue date: 2015 Jun
- Impact of target volume segmentation accuracy and variability on treatment planning for 4D-CT-based non-small cell lung cancer radiotherapy.
- Authors: Martin S, Johnson C, Brophy M, Palma DA, Barron JL, Beauchemin SS, Louie AV, Yu E, Yaremko B, Ahmad B, Rodrigues GB, Gaede S
- Issue date: 2015 Mar
- Observer variation in target volume delineation of lung cancer related to radiation oncologist-computer interaction: a 'Big Brother' evaluation.
- Authors: Steenbakkers RJ, Duppen JC, Fitton I, Deurloo KE, Zijp L, Uitterhoeve AL, Rodrigus PT, Kramer GW, Bussink J, De Jaeger K, Belderbos JS, Hart AA, Nowak PJ, van Herk M, Rasch CR
- Issue date: 2005 Nov
- The impact of training and professional collaboration on the interobserver variation of lung cancer delineations: a multi-institutional study.
- Authors: Mercieca S, Belderbos JSA, van Baardwijk A, Delorme S, van Herk M
- Issue date: 2019 Feb
- Variations in target volume definition for postoperative radiotherapy in stage III non-small-cell lung cancer: analysis of an international contouring study.
- Authors: Spoelstra FO, Senan S, Le Péchoux C, Ishikura S, Casas F, Ball D, Price A, De Ruysscher D, van Sörnsen de Koste JR, Lung Adjuvant Radiotherapy Trial Investigators Group.
- Issue date: 2010 Mar 15