This is a platform alteration: a trial management perspective on the operational aspects of adaptive and platform and umbrella protocols
Clarke, Noel W
AffiliationMRC Clinical Trials Unit at UCL, Institute of Clinical Trials and Methodology, UCL, 90 High Holborn, London, WC1V 6LJ, UK
MetadataShow full item record
AbstractBACKGROUND: There are limited research and literature on the trial management challenges encountered in running adaptive platform trials. This trial design allows both (1) the seamless addition of new research comparisons when compelling clinical and scientific research questions emerge, and (2) early stopping of accrual to individual comparisons that do not show sufficient activity without affecting other active comparisons. Adaptive platform design trials also offer many potential benefits over traditional trials, from faster time to accrual to contemporaneously recruiting multiple research comparisons, added flexibility to focus on more promising research comparisons via pre-planned interim analyses and potentially shorter time to primary results. We share here our experiences from a trial management perspective, highlighting the challenges and successes. METHODS: We evaluated the operational aspects of making changes to these adaptive platform trials and identified both common and trial-specific challenges. The operational steps and challenges linked to both the addition of new research comparisons and stopping recruitment following pre-planned interim analysis were considered in our evaluation. RESULTS: Specific operational challenges in these adaptive platform protocols, additional to those in traditional two-arm trials, were identified. Key lessons are presented describing some of the solutions and considerations over conducting these trials. Careful consideration on the practicality of the protocol structure (modular versus single protocol), the longevity and continuity of trial oversight committees, and having clear clinical and scientific criteria for the addition of new research comparisons were identified as some of the most common challenges. CONCLUSIONS: Understanding the operational complexities associated with running adaptive platform protocols is paramount for their conduct, adaptive platform trials offer an efficient model to run randomised controlled trials and we are continuing to work to reduce further the effort required from an operational perspective.
CitationSchiavone F, Bathia R, Letchemanan K, Masters L, Amos C, Bara A, et al. This is a platform alteration: a trial management perspective on the operational aspects of adaptive and platform and umbrella protocols. Trials. 2019;20(1):264.
- Changing platforms without stopping the train: experiences of data management and data management systems when adapting platform protocols by adding and closing comparisons.
- Authors: Hague D, Townsend S, Masters L, Rauchenberger M, Van Looy N, Diaz-Montana C, Gannon M, James N, Maughan T, Parmar MKB, Brown L, Sydes MR, STAMPEDE and FOCUS4 investigators.
- Issue date: 2019 May 29
- A platform trial in practice: adding a new experimental research arm to the ongoing confirmatory FLAIR trial in chronic lymphocytic leukaemia.
- Authors: Howard DR, Hockaday A, Brown JM, Gregory WM, Todd S, Munir T, Oughton JB, Dimbleby C, Hillmen P
- Issue date: 2021 Jan 8
- Flexible trial design in practice - stopping arms for lack-of-benefit and adding research arms mid-trial in STAMPEDE: a multi-arm multi-stage randomized controlled trial.
- Authors: Sydes MR, Parmar MK, Mason MD, Clarke NW, Amos C, Anderson J, de Bono J, Dearnaley DP, Dwyer J, Green C, Jovic G, Ritchie AW, Russell JM, Sanders K, Thalmann G, James ND
- Issue date: 2012 Sep 15
- Experiences of running a stratified medicine adaptive platform trial: Challenges and lessons learned from 10 years of the FOCUS4 trial in metastatic colorectal cancer.
- Authors: Brown LC, Graham J, Fisher D, Adams R, Seligmann J, Seymour M, Kaplan R, Yates E, Parmar M, Richman SD, Quirke P, Butler R, Shiu K, Middleton G, Samuel L, Wilson RH, Maughan TS, FOCUS4 Trial Investigators.
- Issue date: 2022 Apr
- Practical guidance for running late-phase platform protocols for clinical trials: lessons from experienced UK clinical trials units.
- Authors: Love SB, Cafferty F, Snowdon C, Carty K, Savage J, Pallmann P, McParland L, Brown L, Masters L, Schiavone F, Hague D, Townsend S, Amos C, South A, Sturgeon K, Langley R, Maughan T, James N, Hall E, Kernaghan S, Bliss J, Turner N, Tutt A, Yap C, Firth C, Kong A, Mehanna H, Watts C, Hills R, Thomas I, Copland M, Bell S, Sebag-Montefiore D, Jones R, Parmar MKB, Sydes MR
- Issue date: 2022 Sep 6