Automated delineation of radiotherapy volumes: are we going in the right direction?
Affiliation
The Christie Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, ManchesterIssue Date
2013-01
Metadata
Show full item recordAbstract
Rapid and accurate delineation of target volumes and multiple organs at risk, within the enduring International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurement framework, is now hugely important in radiotherapy, owing to the rapid proliferation of intensity-modulated radiotherapy and the advent of four-dimensional image-guided adaption. Nevertheless, delineation is still generally clinically performed with little if any machine assistance, even though it is both time-consuming and prone to interobserver variation. Currently available segmentation tools include those based on image greyscale interrogation, statistical shape modelling and body atlas-based methods. However, all too often these are not able to match the accuracy of the expert clinician, which remains the universally acknowledged gold standard. In this article we suggest that current methods are fundamentally limited by their lack of ability to incorporate essential human clinical decision-making into the underlying models. Hybrid techniques that utilise prior knowledge, make sophisticated use of greyscale information and allow clinical expertise to be integrated are needed. This may require a change in focus from automated segmentation to machine-assisted delineation. Similarly, new metrics of image quality reflecting fitness for purpose would be extremely valuable. We conclude that methods need to be developed to take account of the clinician's expertise and honed visual processing capabilities as much as the underlying, clinically meaningful information content of the image data being interrogated. We illustrate our observations and suggestions through our own experiences with two software tools developed as part of research council-funded projects.Citation
Automated delineation of radiotherapy volumes: are we going in the right direction? 2013, 86 (1021):20110718 Br J RadiolJournal
British Journal of RadiologyDOI
10.1259/bjr.20110718PubMed ID
23239689Type
ArticleLanguage
enISSN
1748-880Xae974a485f413a2113503eed53cd6c53
10.1259/bjr.20110718
Scopus Count
Collections
Related articles
- A statistical modeling approach for evaluating auto-segmentation methods for image-guided radiotherapy.
- Authors: Yang J, Wei C, Zhang L, Zhang Y, Blum RS, Dong L
- Issue date: 2012 Sep
- The impact of tumor motion upon CT image integrity and target delineation.
- Authors: Gagné IM, Robinson DM
- Issue date: 2004 Dec
- Quantifying the accuracy of automated structure segmentation in 4D CT images using a deformable image registration algorithm.
- Authors: Wijesooriya K, Weiss E, Dill V, Dong L, Mohan R, Joshi S, Keall PJ
- Issue date: 2008 Apr
- Weights and topology: a study of the effects of graph construction on 3D image segmentation.
- Authors: Grady L, Jolly MP
- Issue date: 2008
- Interactive semiautomatic contour delineation using statistical conditional random fields framework.
- Authors: Hu YC, Grossberg MD, Wu A, Riaz N, Perez C, Mageras GS
- Issue date: 2012 Jul